Quedate.caES
My refugee claim was rejected: what options do I have?

My refugee claim was rejected: what options do I have?

By the Quédate.ca team

Receiving a negative decision after a refugee hearing can be devastating. You may have spent months or years waiting, gathering documents and explaining difficult experiences and why you cannot return to your country.

It is natural to feel afraid, frustrated or confused. You may wonder whether you must leave Canada immediately or whether there is still a way to have the decision reviewed. The answer depends on your case.

A negative decision does not give everyone the same options, but it does not mean you should assume nothing more can be done. Some people can appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division (RAD); others may apply for judicial review at the Federal Court. At a later stage, and under specific conditions, a Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA) or a humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) application may also be possible.

Act promptly, keep your documents and seek individual legal advice. Some deadlines are short and do not stop while you decide what to do.

First, understand the decision you received

Not every negative decision comes from the same authority. The Refugee Protection Division (RPD) may have refused your claim after a hearing; the RAD may have upheld a refusal on appeal; or IRCC may have refused a PRRA.

These decisions require different responses. The decision-maker, reasons, date of notification and procedural history all matter when identifying your options.

Keep the complete decision, including the notice and written reasons. Record when and how you received it: by mail, through your representative or electronically. Do not rely only on the words “claim rejected.” The reasons explain the decision and are needed to assess what comes next.

If you have a lawyer or authorized representative, contact them immediately and ask about the decision, deadlines and options. If you do not have a representative, seek advice without waiting until a deadline is close.

Appealing to the RAD: asking for review of an RPD decision

If the RPD refused your refugee claim, one of the first questions is whether you have a right to appeal to the RAD. Both divisions are part of the IRB, but they have different roles. The RAD reviews RPD decisions and considers whether errors justify intervention.

An appeal normally requires more than saying “I disagree.” It is necessary to identify the errors and explain why they matter to the outcome. For example, an appeal might examine how the RPD assessed evidence, understood a person's explanations or applied the law to the facts. Arguments must be grounded in the record and written reasons.

The RAD normally decides on the documents. There is not always a new hearing, and new evidence is subject to specific rules. A professional can assess what may be submitted and how.

Not everyone can appeal to the RAD

The law does not permit an RAD appeal in certain situations, which may include findings that a claim has no credible basis or is manifestly unfounded. Restrictions also apply to certain claims made at the United States land border under an exception to the Safe Third Country Agreement, and to claims declared abandoned or withdrawn.

This does not mean everyone in those situations has no way to seek review. The RAD may not be available, so the possibility of Federal Court review or another measure needs to be assessed. See the IRB refugee appeal guide.

How much time is there to appeal?

Generally, the Notice of Appeal must be filed within 15 days after receiving the RPD's written reasons. The Appellant's Record, containing the documents and arguments needed to complete or “perfect” the appeal, must then be filed.

Although the rules provide 30 days to perfect an appeal, an IRB practice notice extends that period to 45 days from receipt of the written reasons until further notice. The 45 days do not begin after filing the notice: both periods are counted from the applicable receipt of the reasons.

These deadlines are normally expressed in calendar days, but the exact due date can depend on how the decision was served and applicable counting rules. Do not calculate it solely from the date printed on the letter. See how to file an appeal.

If a deadline has passed, do not assume there is no possibility of action. An extension may be requested, but act without delay and explain why the deadline was missed. An extension is not automatic.

Judicial review at the Federal Court

Judicial review differs from an RAD appeal. The Federal Court considers whether there is a legal reason to intervene in an administrative decision, including, depending on the case, whether the decision was reasonable or the process fair. It is not simply a new refugee hearing before a judge.

Generally, the process starts with an application for permission, called “leave,” for the Court to review the decision. If leave is granted, the case proceeds to judicial review. If the Court intervenes, it may set aside the decision and send the case back for reconsideration. This does not automatically mean the person wins refugee protection; another decision-maker will normally reconsider the case in accordance with the Court's instructions. See IRCC's explanation of Federal Court review.

For immigration matters arising in Canada, the general deadline to apply for leave and judicial review is 15 days after notification of or knowledge of the decision. Different rules apply to matters arising outside Canada, and an extension can be requested in certain circumstances.

People cannot always choose freely between an RAD appeal and going directly to Court. Where an appeal right exists, it may have to be exhausted first. A lawyer should review the decision and full history before choosing a route. See the Federal Court procedural chart.

Does an appeal or judicial review stop removal from Canada?

Do not assume that filing any application automatically stops a removal order. The effect depends on the route used, the decision under review and applicable exceptions.

For example, the regulations provide a stay of removal in certain judicial reviews of negative RAD decisions, but there are exceptions. Judicial review directly challenging an RPD decision can have different consequences. Seeking an extension of time may affect an automatic stay in some circumstances.

If you have a removal order, a Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) appointment or a departure date, tell the lawyer reviewing your case immediately. In some cases it may be necessary to ask the Court for a stay of removal. That is separate from judicial review and requires its own assessment and preparation. See section 231 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations.

Do not ignore CBSA communications or assume removal is stopped without an assessment of your particular situation.

What is a PRRA and when might it be available?

A Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA) is different from an appeal or judicial review. It assesses certain risks a person might face if removed from Canada. It is not a new refugee hearing or an automatic appeal of the previous decision.

When CBSA starts or continues the removal process, an officer checks eligibility and advises whether the person may apply. IRCC states that an application can be made only when a CBSA officer says the person is eligible.

In many cases a 12-month restriction applies after the last relevant negative decision. There may be exceptions, such as a government exemption for certain people from a particular country whose decisions were received within specified dates.

Do not assume that a few months after a hearing is enough, or that a PRRA will always be offered immediately after a refusal. Some categories of people may not be eligible. Check IRCC's PRRA eligibility rules.

Once notified of eligibility, read the instructions and deadlines carefully. Missing the application or document deadline can have serious consequences. Our article I was offered a PRRA in Canada: what does it mean and what happens now? explains more.

Is a humanitarian application another way to appeal a refugee decision?

No. An application on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, or H&C, is not an appeal of a refugee decision and does not replace a PRRA. It is an exceptional permanent residence application. IRCC may consider a person's establishment in Canada, family ties, the best interests of affected children and other relevant humanitarian circumstances.

A family's children's needs, schooling, ties to Canada or the consequences of separation may matter, but the factors must be explained and supported with evidence. Approval is not automatic because someone has children or has lived in Canada for a period of time.

Restrictions also apply. Generally, a person whose refugee claim was refused, abandoned or withdrawn may face a 12-month restriction on applying for H&C relief, subject to specific rules and exceptions. IRCC describes exceptions including certain situations involving a direct adverse effect on a child under 18 or a life-threatening medical condition because adequate care is unavailable in the relevant country.

An exception must be assessed and demonstrated, not assumed. Filing an H&C application should not be confused with obtaining an automatic stay of removal. See IRCC's H&C information.

Family members may have different situations

Not every family member necessarily receives the same decision or has the same procedural history. A mother and child might be accepted while another family member's claim is refused; relatives may also have arrived at different times or have separate proceedings.

Do not assume one answer fits everyone. Identify what happened to each person, which documents they received and how family decisions relate. Also review practical consequences for work permits, health coverage, identity documents, children's education and communications with IRCC or CBSA. Some obligations and benefits can change.

What you can do from the first day

Organize the complete decision letter, written reasons and date received, your Basis of Claim (BOC), narrative, evidence, IRB communications and any CBSA document concerning possible removal.

If you had a representative, request a copy of your file and confirm who will review an appeal or judicial review. Do not assume hearing representation automatically includes later stages; it depends on your agreement.

Seek a legal assessment that addresses at least these questions:

  • Which authority made the decision and why was the claim refused?
  • Is there a right to appeal to the RAD?
  • What is the exact deadline and when does it start?
  • Is there a removal order, and is removal stayed?
  • Is there an upcoming CBSA appointment?
  • Which options are available now and which might be considered later?

Do not wait for “perfect evidence” before seeking advice. With short deadlines, first identify what needs to be done and when.

A negative decision calls for clarity

Every case needs individual review. An RAD appeal, judicial review, PRRA and H&C application have different purposes and requirements. Some may be available immediately; others depend on an invitation, deadlines or specific conditions. None guarantees that a person can stay in Canada.

Understand your decision, check the applicable deadlines and obtain professional guidance before acting. A careful and timely review can help identify the options actually available in your situation.

Official sources

Important notice: This article was prepared by the Quédate.ca team for educational and informational purposes only. It is not legal advice, does not create a lawyer-client or consultant-client relationship and does not replace an individual assessment by an authorized legal representative. Canadian immigration and refugee laws, regulations, policies and procedures can change. Before acting or making a decision, check current law and official information applicable to your situation and, when appropriate, obtain authorized professional advice.

Preparing a PRRA, or know someone who is? Explore our educational guide.

Explore the PRRA guide

Compartir:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Últimas Noticias